ChatterBank1 min ago
Man In List Of Top Women.
Is the world going mad?
https:/
I suspect I'm going to be lambasted by some, but this is absurd isn't it?
I can't get on board with all this 'gender fluidity' nonsense, and therefore this story would normally amuse me, but the fact that people are taking this sort of patent ridiculousness seriously suggests to me that people are losing the plot.
Some people are becoming so achingly right-on that they're endorsing rubbish like this - I genuinely find it head-scratching.
If Billy Vunipola decides that at the next women's rugby world cup he's going to 'identify' as a woman for the duration, would he be allowed to play? And if not, why not?
Can I self-identify as a woman on Monday evening when I go swimming, because there's an absolutely stunning yummy-mummy that goes, and I'd like to see her getting changed? And if not, why not?
Yes, my tongue is firmly wedged in my cheek - but I think it has to be when faced with this sort of total cobblers.
https:/
I suspect I'm going to be lambasted by some, but this is absurd isn't it?
I can't get on board with all this 'gender fluidity' nonsense, and therefore this story would normally amuse me, but the fact that people are taking this sort of patent ridiculousness seriously suggests to me that people are losing the plot.
Some people are becoming so achingly right-on that they're endorsing rubbish like this - I genuinely find it head-scratching.
If Billy Vunipola decides that at the next women's rugby world cup he's going to 'identify' as a woman for the duration, would he be allowed to play? And if not, why not?
Can I self-identify as a woman on Monday evening when I go swimming, because there's an absolutely stunning yummy-mummy that goes, and I'd like to see her getting changed? And if not, why not?
Yes, my tongue is firmly wedged in my cheek - but I think it has to be when faced with this sort of total cobblers.
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Deskdiary. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
If Semenya is a chap, what are we basing this on?
Is it because somwone looked at her on a telly screen and came to the conclusion because she has manly features?
Prudie / Talbot - yes. In this case, it doesn’t affect me, so I don’t care.
In the same way that I really don’t care how strip mining has affected the local economies of towns in West Virginia. Yes, it’s important, but I cannot sit around worrying about thing that don’t affect me.
So yes - if someone describes themselves as transsexual, intersex or gender fluid, I have enough going on with my life not to really be bothered by it.
Is it because somwone looked at her on a telly screen and came to the conclusion because she has manly features?
Prudie / Talbot - yes. In this case, it doesn’t affect me, so I don’t care.
In the same way that I really don’t care how strip mining has affected the local economies of towns in West Virginia. Yes, it’s important, but I cannot sit around worrying about thing that don’t affect me.
So yes - if someone describes themselves as transsexual, intersex or gender fluid, I have enough going on with my life not to really be bothered by it.
With the greatest of respect to Pixie, Caster Semenya's gender is not something you can just assert, based on pictures and unsubstantiated reports, to be other than how she is usually identified. It's offensive to deny someone's identity in that way, in particular in this case when it's ill-informed, bigoted, and at odds with all of her competitors and many official bodies.
On the other hand, complaining about Philip/Pippa's place in this list is understandable, and I can't say I'm inclined to comment on that example further.
On the other hand, complaining about Philip/Pippa's place in this list is understandable, and I can't say I'm inclined to comment on that example further.
///...it is the XY chromosome, testes and lack of ovaries and uterus. ///
You stated this yesterday, pixie, and couldn't provide any evidence that didn't include the discredited Australian report.
Once again, any discussion about Caster Semenya has absolutely nothing to do with whether Philip Bunce should have been placed on a list of women notable women because he occasionally dresses as a woman.
You stated this yesterday, pixie, and couldn't provide any evidence that didn't include the discredited Australian report.
Once again, any discussion about Caster Semenya has absolutely nothing to do with whether Philip Bunce should have been placed on a list of women notable women because he occasionally dresses as a woman.
