//Think you need to take a closer look at the figures NJ.//
You on't need to get too bogged down, maggie.
The UK as a whole currently runs an annual deficit of around £24bn (that is, it spends that amount more than it takes in taxes). Scotland (with about 8% of the population) accounts for a little over half that deficit. Public spending per head in Scotland is around £2,000 more than that in England. The Westminster government is having to borrow around £12bn per annum so that the Scots can enjoy this additional spending. You can examine the figures any way you like but the inescapable fact is that Scotland as a whole enjoys considerable financial support from English taxpayers.