Film, Media & TV0 min ago
Covid Projections
Some interesting graphs here.
Hope the worst case projections are wrong.
https:/
What do you make of them ?
Hope the worst case projections are wrong.
https:/
What do you make of them ?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Gromit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
I'm not sure of the point of these Gromit?
The 'universal 95% mask use' target seem's meaningless. Whose targets that? Is it for all situations.
And how can you project what social distancing behaviour will be- why is there projection any more than mine. My projection is social distancing might improve abit, then dip over Xmas as people party, and then improve again when hospital rates shoot up, but lets hope its all wrong and the boosters plus vaxxing 12-18 plus more social responsibility all helps
The 'universal 95% mask use' target seem's meaningless. Whose targets that? Is it for all situations.
And how can you project what social distancing behaviour will be- why is there projection any more than mine. My projection is social distancing might improve abit, then dip over Xmas as people party, and then improve again when hospital rates shoot up, but lets hope its all wrong and the boosters plus vaxxing 12-18 plus more social responsibility all helps
Ah- sorry, first time it just opened and gave me the masks and social distance projections but I now see that I can tab back to get more graphs so will have alook. But for most people projections arent trusted. Some will see it as more project fear/scaremongering/lies. Others will say so what I'll just do the best I can for me and family while getting on with life as best I can
//…and dont care who ridicules me on here for doing so.//
I don’t believe anybody on here has ridiculed you, bob (not as far as I can see anyway). What some people may have done is to question your decision, which is not quite the same. You mentioned in another thread that people will not wear masks “even when told to.” In England there is no legal requirement to wear masks. People can be asked to wear them (and businesses can refuse service if they fail to comply) but nobody can be “told” to wear one. I appreciate the situation is different in Wales.
Back to the charts, they make no sense. As an example, the chart of “Daily deaths” projects, at the beginning of January ‘22, 1,056 deaths as a worst case with just 53 if we all wear masks. I’ll not argue again the efficacy or otherwise of face coverings, but perhaps somebody can explain how, if we all wore them, it would decrease the daily deaths by 95%.
//Is the rest of Europe counting deaths in the same way we are?//
It almost certainly isn’t. It probably isn’t counting hospitalisations in the same way either. I know two people who have died in the last 18 months who were both included in the 139k reported Covid deaths. Neither would have survived significantly longer had they not contracted Covid and both caught it in hospital, where they had been admitted – Covid free - for something else. Daily Covid hospitalisations include patients who had been admitted free of the virus but subsequently tested positive after admission (again, for something else). Many older people (and some younger) who have multiple health problems eventually succumb to a widespread common disease which was not originally among their ailments. Pneumonia is a very common cause of death among such people and they die from it because their immune system is badly compromised as a result of their underlying health conditions. To put it crudely, pneumonia “finishes them off” and that is what is happening to many patients who die from Covid. I appreciate that it is difficult to separate these from people who die plainly and simply from Covid and nothing else but it is disingenuous to say they all died as a result of Covid (or pneumonia).
I don’t know how other countries measure their deaths but I doubt they would include a 95 year old who had been suffering from serious kidney and liver problems and who had spent much of the two years prior to her death in hospital. Nor, I doubt, would they include a 75 year old who had been diagnosed with terminal cancer before the pandemic began and who was told she would not see the following summer. But those were the circumstances which led to my two friends being added to the list of “Covid” deaths, so you will forgive me if I treat the figure of 139k with a little suspicion.
I don’t believe anybody on here has ridiculed you, bob (not as far as I can see anyway). What some people may have done is to question your decision, which is not quite the same. You mentioned in another thread that people will not wear masks “even when told to.” In England there is no legal requirement to wear masks. People can be asked to wear them (and businesses can refuse service if they fail to comply) but nobody can be “told” to wear one. I appreciate the situation is different in Wales.
Back to the charts, they make no sense. As an example, the chart of “Daily deaths” projects, at the beginning of January ‘22, 1,056 deaths as a worst case with just 53 if we all wear masks. I’ll not argue again the efficacy or otherwise of face coverings, but perhaps somebody can explain how, if we all wore them, it would decrease the daily deaths by 95%.
//Is the rest of Europe counting deaths in the same way we are?//
It almost certainly isn’t. It probably isn’t counting hospitalisations in the same way either. I know two people who have died in the last 18 months who were both included in the 139k reported Covid deaths. Neither would have survived significantly longer had they not contracted Covid and both caught it in hospital, where they had been admitted – Covid free - for something else. Daily Covid hospitalisations include patients who had been admitted free of the virus but subsequently tested positive after admission (again, for something else). Many older people (and some younger) who have multiple health problems eventually succumb to a widespread common disease which was not originally among their ailments. Pneumonia is a very common cause of death among such people and they die from it because their immune system is badly compromised as a result of their underlying health conditions. To put it crudely, pneumonia “finishes them off” and that is what is happening to many patients who die from Covid. I appreciate that it is difficult to separate these from people who die plainly and simply from Covid and nothing else but it is disingenuous to say they all died as a result of Covid (or pneumonia).
I don’t know how other countries measure their deaths but I doubt they would include a 95 year old who had been suffering from serious kidney and liver problems and who had spent much of the two years prior to her death in hospital. Nor, I doubt, would they include a 75 year old who had been diagnosed with terminal cancer before the pandemic began and who was told she would not see the following summer. But those were the circumstances which led to my two friends being added to the list of “Covid” deaths, so you will forgive me if I treat the figure of 139k with a little suspicion.
I have tosho phobia I have
I go mad ( OK madder ) when I see tosh and it doesnt have to be first grade tosh eeva
Nor, I doubt, would they include a 75 year old who had been diagnosed with terminal cancer before the pandemic began and who was told she would not see the following summer.
writes an intellect
and so my lord if the old lady is feeling old, and "wont see next year my lord coz I old and ill I am nearny nearny" and she is! so if she falls under a bus or is pushed then the cause of death must be - being old and having terminal cancer - clear acquittal of pusher
really my Lord I dont think so
I go mad ( OK madder ) when I see tosh and it doesnt have to be first grade tosh eeva
Nor, I doubt, would they include a 75 year old who had been diagnosed with terminal cancer before the pandemic began and who was told she would not see the following summer.
writes an intellect
and so my lord if the old lady is feeling old, and "wont see next year my lord coz I old and ill I am nearny nearny" and she is! so if she falls under a bus or is pushed then the cause of death must be - being old and having terminal cancer - clear acquittal of pusher
really my Lord I dont think so
// so you will forgive me if I treat the figure of 139k with a little suspicion.//
Agreed -some other measure's suggest it should be higher, eg excess deaths, and over 162000 with Covid mentioned on death certificate. For every one with Covid whose knocked down by a bus or has a heart attack theres probably at least one that dies with covid maybe alone at home but hadnt been tested
Agreed -some other measure's suggest it should be higher, eg excess deaths, and over 162000 with Covid mentioned on death certificate. For every one with Covid whose knocked down by a bus or has a heart attack theres probably at least one that dies with covid maybe alone at home but hadnt been tested
NJ
5 March
//Neil Ferguson at Imperial College London gave evidence today to the UK’s parliamentary select committee on science and technology as part of an inquiry into the nation’s response to the coronavirus outbreak.
He said that UK deaths from the disease are now unlikely to exceed 20,000, and could be much lower. //
28 March.
// According to Imperial College London’s new predictions, Britain is on course for around 5,700 deaths //
We will be on 140,000 deaths any day.
5 March
//Neil Ferguson at Imperial College London gave evidence today to the UK’s parliamentary select committee on science and technology as part of an inquiry into the nation’s response to the coronavirus outbreak.
He said that UK deaths from the disease are now unlikely to exceed 20,000, and could be much lower. //
28 March.
// According to Imperial College London’s new predictions, Britain is on course for around 5,700 deaths //
We will be on 140,000 deaths any day.
too low a projection
one coming up
whitty - before the kissy kissy in the park
I said 20 000 ( total deaths ) and thought 50 000 far too many
and all the slowness in locking down, PPE etc - that was due to over projection and caution
no sirree ! due to doubt about the figures and fracking around ( wiv Boris literally - [he made a baby wiv Carrul for the Abers to who do not 'do' subtlety])
and believing nay - KNOWING in that crazy thread sense - that the figures would be lower
one coming up
whitty - before the kissy kissy in the park
I said 20 000 ( total deaths ) and thought 50 000 far too many
and all the slowness in locking down, PPE etc - that was due to over projection and caution
no sirree ! due to doubt about the figures and fracking around ( wiv Boris literally - [he made a baby wiv Carrul for the Abers to who do not 'do' subtlety])
and believing nay - KNOWING in that crazy thread sense - that the figures would be lower
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.