Crosswords0 min ago
'Excess Profits'
24 Answers
is a ridiculous phrase. Businesses exist to make profits. If a company makes a million one year, then three million the next year, what proportion of the increase is somehow 'excessive'. The point is not what they make but how they are taxed. Many may want to see a higher corporation tax rate and many may not. And that's the political decision.
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Paigntonian. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
They may be there to make a profit but a) overcharging because they can leading to more than morally acceptable can reasonably be considered excessive, and b) getting lucky with circumstances that enrich the company despite no effort on their part to deserve it, while causing hardship to the population, can also reasonably be considered excessive. It's all about morals & morality.
i do agree though that private companies exist to create value for shareholders and nothing else and so cannot really be blamed for trying… the issue is that such a basic commodity that everyone needs to live was entrusted to private companies in the first place when they are not suitable custodians for such a vital industry… That situation should be reversed!
The profits don't just disappear into a black hole. They are re-invested in the business or distributed as dividends to investors who are - a multitude of "little" people & more significantly, large organisations such as pension funds etc. who use those profits to provide income for lots of "little" people! What goes around comes around.
The wealth is shared anyway by way of increased salaries and bonuses for the workers (who are taxed on earnings) & share dividends. People then go out and buy things with this money and are taxed on that.
This is basic economics in a capitalist society. Anything else is a step down the road to socialism.
This is basic economics in a capitalist society. Anything else is a step down the road to socialism.
what folk are forgetting is that in Covid, energy companies took a hammering - and anyway, when one looks at other business performance like Return on Investment, Return on Equity or Assets, their figures even with these so-called elevated profits are only marginally elevated and will be going down as the oil price falls back as I predicted it would once the supply network rebalanced after the G20 largely boycotted Putain's oil. Gas will come spiralling down when some Kremlin general plugs him, this ending the war.
Last year BPs profits doubled.
This year they are set to triple.
BP have done precisely nothing to make all that extra money. It is not reward for being savvy or investing in the business, it is money they have got because of circumstances out of their control. A windfall.
Retrospect taxing would normally be a very bad thing to do, but the high prices are severely affecting their end users, making them a lot poorer. They are expecting a windfall tax. They will still exceedingly high profits after a tax grab.
This year they are set to triple.
BP have done precisely nothing to make all that extra money. It is not reward for being savvy or investing in the business, it is money they have got because of circumstances out of their control. A windfall.
Retrospect taxing would normally be a very bad thing to do, but the high prices are severely affecting their end users, making them a lot poorer. They are expecting a windfall tax. They will still exceedingly high profits after a tax grab.
