ChatterBank6 mins ago
Muslims who fought for Britain
I only became aware of this when scanning through a post from yesterday:
http://www.metro.co.u...tten-on-armistice-day
Why is it that the contribution from Muslim and Commonwealth troops during the last two world wars isn't celebrated?
How comes none of us knows about the "2.5million men and women who came over to do their bit in World War II"?
Is it because it flies in the face of the usual Islamophobic rhetoric spouted by the dailymailers (who want everyone to believe that "yer typical Muslim is a banner-waving extremist")?
Can anyone explain this oddity?
http://www.metro.co.u...tten-on-armistice-day
Why is it that the contribution from Muslim and Commonwealth troops during the last two world wars isn't celebrated?
How comes none of us knows about the "2.5million men and women who came over to do their bit in World War II"?
Is it because it flies in the face of the usual Islamophobic rhetoric spouted by the dailymailers (who want everyone to believe that "yer typical Muslim is a banner-waving extremist")?
Can anyone explain this oddity?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by sp1814. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
123everton
/// There's a famous poster from WW2 with a defiant Tommy standing on the white cliffs shaking his fist "very well alone!" he declares ///
Another typical anti British post from you, I don't know how you dare use the name of a proud English township in your username.
That poster you refer to would only be symbolic, and not to be taken literally as you have done for your own convenience.
Since your interest in WW2 posters, I think these are appropriate in the circumstances.
http://www.st-andrews...images3/together1.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies1.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies2.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies3.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies4.jpg
/// There's a famous poster from WW2 with a defiant Tommy standing on the white cliffs shaking his fist "very well alone!" he declares ///
Another typical anti British post from you, I don't know how you dare use the name of a proud English township in your username.
That poster you refer to would only be symbolic, and not to be taken literally as you have done for your own convenience.
Since your interest in WW2 posters, I think these are appropriate in the circumstances.
http://www.st-andrews...images3/together1.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies1.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies2.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies3.jpg
http://www.st-andrews...images3/colonies4.jpg
AOG, it's not anti British to say we weren't alone.
It's an insult to thousands of brave Australian, Kiwis, South Africans, Indians etc to deny them their RIGHTFUL place in our victory.
I'll ask you again how many Australians served in the Italian campaign?
And as for the posters, one I'd question where they were posted, I'm guessing it was for a colonial audience (no conscription in the colonies or Commonwealth), I do however feel that it's a pity that from "together" we got to "rivers of blood" in little over twenty years, I digress....
It's an insult to thousands of brave Australian, Kiwis, South Africans, Indians etc to deny them their RIGHTFUL place in our victory.
I'll ask you again how many Australians served in the Italian campaign?
And as for the posters, one I'd question where they were posted, I'm guessing it was for a colonial audience (no conscription in the colonies or Commonwealth), I do however feel that it's a pity that from "together" we got to "rivers of blood" in little over twenty years, I digress....
sp1814
/// It's all too easy nowadays to throw the 'R' word around.///
Wow that is rich coming from you, the person who will use the word at a drop of a hat.
.
/// it flies in the face of the usual Islamophobic rhetoric spouted by the dailymailers (who want everyone to believe that "yer typical Muslim is a banner-waving extremist")? ///
Although not actually pointing the finger at any particular race, your reference to the Dailymailers makes it obvious who you mean.
/// It's all too easy nowadays to throw the 'R' word around.///
Wow that is rich coming from you, the person who will use the word at a drop of a hat.
.
/// it flies in the face of the usual Islamophobic rhetoric spouted by the dailymailers (who want everyone to believe that "yer typical Muslim is a banner-waving extremist")? ///
Although not actually pointing the finger at any particular race, your reference to the Dailymailers makes it obvious who you mean.
We need to remember that the Indians fought to defend freedoms that we ourselves denied them at home, this in spite of the fact that Hitler offered the Indians indepence if they joined his cause.
They declined enmasse.
I'm still waiting for AOG to tell me how many Australians were serving in Italy....
They declined enmasse.
I'm still waiting for AOG to tell me how many Australians were serving in Italy....
Davethedog
/// Everton is a township? I wish I had your knowledge and I.Q ///
Nothing clever, with the help from Google, and one can will prove most things.
http://tinyurl.com/3x4vuoh
/// Everton is a township? I wish I had your knowledge and I.Q ///
Nothing clever, with the help from Google, and one can will prove most things.
http://tinyurl.com/3x4vuoh
123everton
/// AOG, it's not anti British to say we weren't alone.///
That's is not what I said, I said you were anti British because you prove yourself to be by all your continuous criticism of the British.
I provide you with authentic WW2 posters showing the Empire/Commonwealth forces pulling together to fight a foreign foe, but you still had to make up a false scenario attached to them.
Strange there has been no comment yet about the Muslim SS.
/// AOG, it's not anti British to say we weren't alone.///
That's is not what I said, I said you were anti British because you prove yourself to be by all your continuous criticism of the British.
I provide you with authentic WW2 posters showing the Empire/Commonwealth forces pulling together to fight a foreign foe, but you still had to make up a false scenario attached to them.
Strange there has been no comment yet about the Muslim SS.
Or the British SS
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page
Although that was via Bing.
Australians in Italy AOG.....
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page
Although that was via Bing.
Australians in Italy AOG.....
http://en.wikipedia.o...ki/British_Free_Corps
That's better, whoops.
That's better, whoops.
I take it you either don't know or won't say how many Australian were serving in Italy, so I'll tell you, none.
The Australians were sent back to Australia after the fall of Libya due to the threat of invasion from Japan.
After a lot of wrangling Churchill managed to keep the New Zealanders for Italy, now here's the crux of why I was asking you this.
The Australians were sent home to defend Australia, the Indians stayed to fight the Italian and Kesselring's German forces, yet the Japanese were on the borders of India at Burma.
So why weren't the Indians sent home to defend hearth and home, if that's all they were there for?
The Australians were sent back to Australia after the fall of Libya due to the threat of invasion from Japan.
After a lot of wrangling Churchill managed to keep the New Zealanders for Italy, now here's the crux of why I was asking you this.
The Australians were sent home to defend Australia, the Indians stayed to fight the Italian and Kesselring's German forces, yet the Japanese were on the borders of India at Burma.
So why weren't the Indians sent home to defend hearth and home, if that's all they were there for?
-- answer removed --
Latest Posts
Quizzes & Puzzles12 mins ago
Quizzes & Puzzles19 mins ago
Quizzes & Puzzles37 mins ago
Quizzes & Puzzles86 mins ago
