ChatterBank4 mins ago
Are religious people mentally imbalanced? (serious questio)
I'm a Paramedic who was bought up Catholic, but no longer follows any God.
The reason for my question is that I recently had a few classroom days with a Mental Health Professional and he stated that Religion is mass paranoia and therefore people who believe in a God are mentally unstable to some degree. He didnt say that they were insane, just that in order for a human to believe in something that is totally unquantifiable, invisible, all powerful and all knowing, requires certain functions in the brain to be switched on (or off I suppose?), and that Atheists such as myself are in fact missing a piece of code somewhere or it's been eliminated from our conciousness.
I'd love to hear from MH Pro's if there are any here, it struck me as quite odd that a Professional could say this so openly. Posted in Science as I'm looking for a Scientific rather than esoteric answer.
The reason for my question is that I recently had a few classroom days with a Mental Health Professional and he stated that Religion is mass paranoia and therefore people who believe in a God are mentally unstable to some degree. He didnt say that they were insane, just that in order for a human to believe in something that is totally unquantifiable, invisible, all powerful and all knowing, requires certain functions in the brain to be switched on (or off I suppose?), and that Atheists such as myself are in fact missing a piece of code somewhere or it's been eliminated from our conciousness.
I'd love to hear from MH Pro's if there are any here, it struck me as quite odd that a Professional could say this so openly. Posted in Science as I'm looking for a Scientific rather than esoteric answer.
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by chirox. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Imbalanced is probably a bit strong.
However there is evidence from separated twin studies that suggests that we are genetically disposed to be either religious or not.
Just waiting for a religious group to take this as evidence for a race of "chosen" people destined to have faith and hence be saved
However there is evidence from separated twin studies that suggests that we are genetically disposed to be either religious or not.
Just waiting for a religious group to take this as evidence for a race of "chosen" people destined to have faith and hence be saved
-- answer removed --
I am not too sure how logical an answer this will be!
I am bipolar and am very anti organised religion. I accept other people's religious beliefs and try to be tolerant about religion. However during periods of mania it appears, my psychiatrist told me, that religion is a major thing that people become obsessed over.
My brother has no mental health problems (he says!) but has similar view about religion as I do.
I don't now if crazy people are driven crazy by religion or if crazy people are attracted to it.
I am bipolar and am very anti organised religion. I accept other people's religious beliefs and try to be tolerant about religion. However during periods of mania it appears, my psychiatrist told me, that religion is a major thing that people become obsessed over.
My brother has no mental health problems (he says!) but has similar view about religion as I do.
I don't now if crazy people are driven crazy by religion or if crazy people are attracted to it.
Well if people claim certain belief in things that have no substantiation; Elvis is alive and living in Cleethorpes, Fairies at the bottom of the garden, being abducted by aliens - they are usually treated as having a mental health issue to some extent.
At the extreme this sort of unsubstantiated belief does segue into diagnosable problems such as schizophrenia. Someone i know was convinced she was a princess and secretly married to Prince Charles. She has spent the past 10 years under medical supervision.
Clinical Therapy training teaches us that we should respect other people's 'model of the world'. I think the heart of this is that there are massive gaps in our understanding of Life, the Universe and Everything. For some of us, we are content to accept and be content with the 'not knowing'.
Others feel a need to fill those gaps with stories, beliefs, myths etc And of course, our species is very creative in inventing these.
Especially when you factor in that many human beings have an issue with the notion of ceasing to be (death) and the other basic needs that Religions satisfy; sense of community, personal significance and certainty.
.
At the extreme this sort of unsubstantiated belief does segue into diagnosable problems such as schizophrenia. Someone i know was convinced she was a princess and secretly married to Prince Charles. She has spent the past 10 years under medical supervision.
Clinical Therapy training teaches us that we should respect other people's 'model of the world'. I think the heart of this is that there are massive gaps in our understanding of Life, the Universe and Everything. For some of us, we are content to accept and be content with the 'not knowing'.
Others feel a need to fill those gaps with stories, beliefs, myths etc And of course, our species is very creative in inventing these.
Especially when you factor in that many human beings have an issue with the notion of ceasing to be (death) and the other basic needs that Religions satisfy; sense of community, personal significance and certainty.
.
-- answer removed --
<<a bit like atheists Zeuhl? >>
No not at all.
I am an atheist ie I don't believe in God - because I have no way of knowing who, what, why of the infinite universe. My stock answer to theological questions from religious people is 'I don't know and with all due respect, neither do you'.
My not knowing is certainly no reason to accept some man-made invention of a supernatural creator - especially as it is so obviously a self-serving, comforting and reassuring idea for people to have.
.
No not at all.
I am an atheist ie I don't believe in God - because I have no way of knowing who, what, why of the infinite universe. My stock answer to theological questions from religious people is 'I don't know and with all due respect, neither do you'.
My not knowing is certainly no reason to accept some man-made invention of a supernatural creator - especially as it is so obviously a self-serving, comforting and reassuring idea for people to have.
.
I don't know, Zeuhl, I've known lots of believers (in various things) in my time, and I can say they've always been peaceful and happy and showing no sign whatever of paranoia or other mental imbalance. (No doubt there are religious nuts, and non-religious nuts too.) I believe there are studies showing religious people are happier people overall.
Among possible conclusions: ah, they're only happy because they're stupid; if only they knew the truth...
or: if believers outnumber non-believers by five to one (that seems to be about the ratio), surely it's the latter who must be considered unbalanced?
Among possible conclusions: ah, they're only happy because they're stupid; if only they knew the truth...
or: if believers outnumber non-believers by five to one (that seems to be about the ratio), surely it's the latter who must be considered unbalanced?
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.