How it Works1 min ago
Ed Miliband - Atheist
42 Answers
He has said that he wants to be the first British Prime Minister
who is an atheist. He also claims he would be the first Jewish PM.
I'm not sure he is correct on either?
who is an atheist. He also claims he would be the first Jewish PM.
I'm not sure he is correct on either?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Graudian. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Apparently it is even more complex than I was led to believe
http://
Makes me feel that a Jew is whoever claims to be one and is accepted by other Jews, maybe.
Meanwhile, who cares what religion a PM is, just so long as they keep secular in their political decisions, and leave they religious faith to their own private moments.
http://
Makes me feel that a Jew is whoever claims to be one and is accepted by other Jews, maybe.
Meanwhile, who cares what religion a PM is, just so long as they keep secular in their political decisions, and leave they religious faith to their own private moments.
I have never understood this thing about being Jewish.
Judaism is a faith, in the same way that Catholicism is. I stopped being a good little Catholic boy, when I stopped being a little boy, so I can't possibly still be called a Catholic can I ? I am an ex-Catholic but an extant Atheist.
So.... if Ed calls himself an Atheist, what damn difference does it make that his Mum was a Jew ? He is what he wants to be and that isn't Jewish !
I am not sure if we have ever had any declared Atheists as PM, but I wouldn't mind betting that some of them at least have paid lip service to
being Christian !
I am reminded of that joke about a young chap, on a trans-European train. He is trying to read his newspaper but the little old lady opposite keeps leaning forward and tapping him on the knee and interrupting him. She keeps asking him if he is Jewish and he patiently replies that, " No, I'm not Jewish"
But she keeps on and on, so eventually he says, in exasperation, " OK, for pity's sake, I'm Jewish !
The old lady replies...." Now thats funny, because you don't look Jewish ! "
Judaism is a faith, in the same way that Catholicism is. I stopped being a good little Catholic boy, when I stopped being a little boy, so I can't possibly still be called a Catholic can I ? I am an ex-Catholic but an extant Atheist.
So.... if Ed calls himself an Atheist, what damn difference does it make that his Mum was a Jew ? He is what he wants to be and that isn't Jewish !
I am not sure if we have ever had any declared Atheists as PM, but I wouldn't mind betting that some of them at least have paid lip service to
being Christian !
I am reminded of that joke about a young chap, on a trans-European train. He is trying to read his newspaper but the little old lady opposite keeps leaning forward and tapping him on the knee and interrupting him. She keeps asking him if he is Jewish and he patiently replies that, " No, I'm not Jewish"
But she keeps on and on, so eventually he says, in exasperation, " OK, for pity's sake, I'm Jewish !
The old lady replies...." Now thats funny, because you don't look Jewish ! "
Is there any evidence that Ed wants to be both an Atheist and a Jew ?
Perhaps he is proud of his Jewish background, and wants to hang on to the
"flavour" of it ?
My background is both Catholic and Irish, and whatever else I might want to do on a Sunday morning instead of going to Mass, I would never want to lose my heritage !
Perhaps he is proud of his Jewish background, and wants to hang on to the
"flavour" of it ?
My background is both Catholic and Irish, and whatever else I might want to do on a Sunday morning instead of going to Mass, I would never want to lose my heritage !
Yes, of course I do Zacs...I have already done so, many, many times !
But I always add, if requested, that I was brought up as a Catholic, and that my Dad was Irish. People should not confuse genetics and belief, and so many Jews seem to do so.
Doctor Jonathan Miller once described himself, on Parkinson, as a Jew but not very Jewish. I see from his Wiki entry, that he now refers to himself as an Atheist.
But I always add, if requested, that I was brought up as a Catholic, and that my Dad was Irish. People should not confuse genetics and belief, and so many Jews seem to do so.
Doctor Jonathan Miller once described himself, on Parkinson, as a Jew but not very Jewish. I see from his Wiki entry, that he now refers to himself as an Atheist.
I understand now Zacs !
I suppose its because Ed identifies with his family's Jewish past. His Mum, who was a Polish Jew, survived the Holocaust and his Dad fled to England during WW2. So although Ed now says he is an Atheist, it must be difficult not to identity with that sort of background, with his family being persecuted for being Jewish.
My father also experienced problems as a young boy, growing up in NI as a Catholic in the 1920's and 1930's, although not on the same scale as the European Jews of course.
I suppose its because Ed identifies with his family's Jewish past. His Mum, who was a Polish Jew, survived the Holocaust and his Dad fled to England during WW2. So although Ed now says he is an Atheist, it must be difficult not to identity with that sort of background, with his family being persecuted for being Jewish.
My father also experienced problems as a young boy, growing up in NI as a Catholic in the 1920's and 1930's, although not on the same scale as the European Jews of course.
Latest Posts
Quizzes & Puzzles7 mins ago
How it Works14 mins ago
Food & Drink15 mins ago
Food & Drink15 mins ago
Food & Drink16 mins ago
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.