Modern science and christianity are irreconcilable.
Christianity was born into a world where science was very basic and hardly existed in any way comparable with its modern form. The greeks had a shot, but no one really understood that as a species we came, like all other species, from a process of evolution; that the processes of thought, willed-action, and memory, were carried out by the jelly-like matter that sits in your head; that no known mental process can be pointed out that cannot be identified as having at least a substrate in this jelly-like matter; that order in the world could come from processes within the world itself. None of this was widely accepted when mainstream religions were born, nor when they were accepted as giving a good depiction of how the world was, and should be accepted as being. Science moved on. We have knowledge that they didn't have. You live in an era with this new knowledge. You do not use it. Many greeks would have. Many disciples of Jesus would reject him because they would make use of this knowledge. If Jesus was reincarnated today he may well spit in the face of modern christians and call them morons, waving his bloody hand at them, shouting 'Back then we had an excuse: we didn't know. You have 2 thousand years of solid scientific advancement, and yet you choose (yes choose) to remain in the dark.' Jesus is turning in his grave.
As for Plato, he'd probably kill you.