....and they did not look like humans but had the same level of intelligence or moreso, would we still be able to maintain that we are created in God's image?
Well, yes and no. It all depends upon your interpretation of 'created in God's image'. If it means we look like him then no. If, however, it means that human beings are endowed with similar personality traits to God, which they are, then yes.
Since we don;t know what God looks like, I guess any sort of being could be made in his image - he might morph into all sorts of forms, depending on how the fancy takes him.
Luna, that was not aimed solely or specifically at you, but if people request privacy then their wishes must be respected, so you're wrong to take it personally. I was simply trying to convey a message here, but if you want to shoot the messenger, fine. Please yourself. Sorry I spoke.