Assisted Dying, Here's Where It Leads.....

[ToraToraTora]

https://news.sky.com/story/depressed-and-desperate-to-die-has-assisted-dying-in-canada-crossed-the-line-13258336

"But although Canada's MAiD was originally intended to be used in exceptional circumstances, repeated challenges have extended the programme to include disability. " - remind you of anything?

[Ellipsis]

It reminds me a lot of the debate before and after the Abortion Act 1967 (and the current debate on Roe v Wade in the USA at present).  One's about start of life, the other's about end of life, one's about "life", the other's about "choice" ... in the end, I think if somebody doesn't want an abortion, it is very important that it is not forced upon them; and likewise, if somebody doesn't want assisting dying, it is very important that it is not forced upon them; but for those that do want it, in both cases, it should be their prerogative.

[Untitled]

interesting comparison ellipsis. i hadn't thought of it like that. 

[Ellipsis]

Thanks, Untitled.

[davebro3]

A it stands if you have the means to go abroad (Dignitas?) it's one law for the rich and another for the poor isn't it?

[davebro3]

As it stands....

[ladybirder]

Sensible as ever Ellipsis.

[Rosetta]

Elipsis, I think the analogy with the abortion debate and assisted dying would be strongly opposed by the anti abortionists who would likely argue that the foetus has no choice in the matter, and this is from me who is pro-cchoice

[Ellipsis]

> the foetus has no choice in the matter

The analogy is not about the foetus, it's about the adult's choices in both scenarios. A terminally ill pregnant woman can legally choose to abort a foetus, but can't legally be assisted to kill herself at a time and a place of her own choice - when both decisions are about what's best for the woman.

If anything, an anti-abortionist might think it would be easier to kill your own legally than another life easily. And let's not forget that killing yourself, or having an abortion, is not impossible even when it's illegal, but it is a lot more risky and brutal.

[Rosetta]

Elipsis, I  don't wish to sidetrack this thread, but your example  of a terminally ill pregnant woman  having an assisted death, whilst being  a fair point, is not typical of the majority of abortions where by and large the only resultant death is that of the foetus, and again I am approaching this from the stand point of a pro-choice supporter

[Ellipsis]

OK two women - friends, sisters, twins or, if you like, don't even know each other. One is pregnant and wants an abortion, the other has a terminal illness and wants assistance in dying - both in their respective personal best interests. One has the choice, legally, the other does not. Is that equitable?

[davebro3]

what you on about? who brought abortion into this?

[ToraToraTora]

stop conflating this with abortion ellipsis, no equivalence.

[Ellipsis]

You're wrong, Tora, but thanks for opinion. 😉