I Wonder What This Little Child Did..

[sandyRoe]

To bring the wrath of the IDF down on it?

 

 

https://www.facebook.com/share/1FK56fTs9d/

[THECORBYLOON]

"so were the babies beheaded by the Hamas monsters."

Is there any substantiated evidence confirming this specific claim?

[ToraToraTora]

18:42 I don't know why the supporters of the terrorists can't see that.

[webbo3]

What did the innocent young girls that were raped, murdered and their bodies mutilated to bring the wrath of Hamas down on them.

[ynnafymmi]

Well,obviously sandy and TCL dont 3T.

[Ken4155]

Fripfrip, et al; We are all aware of how this current situation began. Though the attack by Hamas in October was truly cowardly, merciless  and reprehensible, it shouldn't give Israeli forces carte blanche to discharge their weapons when there is an obvious danger to innocent civilians.

That is my standpoint, based on the orders we had to abide by in Ulster. Not all service personnel are marksmen.

[Ellipsis]

Here we go again. Obfuscate, deflect, excuse ... it's pathetic.

Two wrongs don't make a right, they make two wrongs - and if those two wrongs come are perpetrated by two different parties, then both parties are in the wrong. So the only way anyone can say that the IDF did nothing wrong is to say that what they did was not wrong, not that somebody else did it.

[ynnafymmi]

^Sorry to say this to you two,but the original blame  and only blame for all these deaths in the Middle East lie fairly and squarely on the Hamas attack on 07/10/2023.No Hamas terrorist attack and all these innocents would still be living.The Hamas terrorists are all directly/indirectly responsible for all these deaths.

[Ellipsis]

What you say makes no rational or logical sense, it's your emotional response.

[ynnafymmi]

Are you denying that the 07/10/2023 was the catalyst for the past year and a half of bloodshed ellipsis?

[ToraToraTora]

elipsis: "What you say makes no rational or logical sense, it's your emotional response." - err that's the cold logic response. It's the emotional response that blames the victims for for dealing with the terrorists.

[Ellipsis]

For a start, this killing was in the West Bank, not Gaza. But that's by the by. What I'm saying is that if the IDF kills an innocent child, then the fault is the IDF. Much like if I killed you, and you were completely innocent and I didn't even know you, then the fault would be mine, not anybody else's.

[ynnafymmi]

But what im saying ellipsis is that this all started on 07/10/2023.No Hamas terrorist attack on that day and this wee innocent(and a lot more wee innocents)would still be living.Give your head a shake honey.

[Old_Geezer]

Having scanned the BBC link, it seems the incident may have been caused by Palestinian gunmen starting a gunfight. In which case any tragic consequences would be down to them.

 

It's all very well pointing out that some nations opt to not respond and prefer to risk death to forces & public if there is any possibility of collateral injury of death to innocent civilians: but this is not a global command from some deity. Other nations are at liberty to prioritise responding to deter such behaviour, with any incidental injury to the public being the responsibility of those who kicked off.

[Ellipsis]

> Give your head a shake honey.

Another emotional response. Come back when you have a rational argument  ...

[ynnafymmi]

It seems to me that you dont have a rational response.No 07/10/2023,no thousands of wee innocents deaths.By the way im Scottish,i dont do emotional.

[THECORBYLOON]

Any substantiated evidence confirming the claim, "babies [were] beheaded by the Hamas monsters."?

 

[Mozz71]

//They can end this anytime.//

Do you honestly believe that Tora? I'm not convinced that the Israeli government will stop if the hostages were miraculously returned. Both sides have the taste for blood.

[Ken4155]

OG, the first thing you do when 'contact' is made is to seek immediate cover. Not stand there returning gunfire with an enemy who is no doubt firing from their own cover.

And, it is extremely difficult to ascertain exactly where the shots are being fired from. Therefore it is just as extremely difficult to know if you are returning fire in the correct directon.

I wonder if those soldiers responsible for the death of the young lad don't wish they had taken a few more seconds before returning fire.

[wolf63]

ynnafymmi 18:42

Did you notice the date on the BBC article?

This war has been going on for decades.  It will continue as long as there is no much hatred on both sides.

[johnk]

(s)he was taking up space in Gaza