Labour Scraps Doctors' Apprenticeships
News0 min ago
The Miracles Of Israels Four Major Wars.
20 Answers
Israel fought four major wars, in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973.
West Point don't study Israeli tactics, because they don't make sense! They should have lost on all four occasions!
Even atheistic military experts use the word, "miracle," to describe these amazing victories.
So, were they true miracles, or did Israel just get lucky on all four occasions?
I believe that God intervened and gave Israel the victories, and fulfilled His prophecies as written in the Bible thousands of years ago.
If you take God out of the equasion, then how do you explain it all?
West Point don't study Israeli tactics, because they don't make sense! They should have lost on all four occasions!
Even atheistic military experts use the word, "miracle," to describe these amazing victories.
So, were they true miracles, or did Israel just get lucky on all four occasions?
I believe that God intervened and gave Israel the victories, and fulfilled His prophecies as written in the Bible thousands of years ago.
If you take God out of the equasion, then how do you explain it all?
Answers
1 to 20 of 20
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Theland. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
This is from Wiki so you can decide if you believe it or not. Sounds convincing to me, but I don't believe in miracles.
"In a 1993 interview for the Johnson Presidential Library oral history archives U.S. Secretary of Defence Robert McNamara revealed that a Carrier battle group, the U.S. 6th Fleet, already on a training exercise near Gibraltar was re-positioned towards the eastern Mediterranean to defend Israel. The administration "thought the situation was so tense in Israel that perhaps the Syrians, fearing Israel would attack them, or the Russians supporting the Syrians might wish to redress the balance of power and might attack Israel". The Soviets learned of this deployment, which they regarded as offensive in nature, and in a hotline message from Soviet Premier Alexei Kosygin threatened the United States with war.
In a 1983 interview with the Boston Globe McNamara claimed that "We damn near had war." He said Kosygin was angry that "we had turned around a carrier in the Mediterranean." McNamara did not explain how the crisis was resolved.
In his book Six Days veteran BBC journalist Jeremy Bowen claims that on 4 June, 1967 the Israeli ship Miryam left Felixstowe with cases of machine guns, 105 mm tank shells, and armored vehicles in "the latest of many consignments of arms that had been sent secretly to Israel from British and American reserves since the crisis started" and that "Israeli transport planes had been running a 'shuttle service' in and out of RAF Waddington in Lincolnshire". Bowen claims that Harold Wilson had written to Eshkol saying that he was glad to help as long as the utmost secrecy was maintained."
"In a 1993 interview for the Johnson Presidential Library oral history archives U.S. Secretary of Defence Robert McNamara revealed that a Carrier battle group, the U.S. 6th Fleet, already on a training exercise near Gibraltar was re-positioned towards the eastern Mediterranean to defend Israel. The administration "thought the situation was so tense in Israel that perhaps the Syrians, fearing Israel would attack them, or the Russians supporting the Syrians might wish to redress the balance of power and might attack Israel". The Soviets learned of this deployment, which they regarded as offensive in nature, and in a hotline message from Soviet Premier Alexei Kosygin threatened the United States with war.
In a 1983 interview with the Boston Globe McNamara claimed that "We damn near had war." He said Kosygin was angry that "we had turned around a carrier in the Mediterranean." McNamara did not explain how the crisis was resolved.
In his book Six Days veteran BBC journalist Jeremy Bowen claims that on 4 June, 1967 the Israeli ship Miryam left Felixstowe with cases of machine guns, 105 mm tank shells, and armored vehicles in "the latest of many consignments of arms that had been sent secretly to Israel from British and American reserves since the crisis started" and that "Israeli transport planes had been running a 'shuttle service' in and out of RAF Waddington in Lincolnshire". Bowen claims that Harold Wilson had written to Eshkol saying that he was glad to help as long as the utmost secrecy was maintained."
Good question Theland, and Gromit, that's a good response.
A miracle is surely a matter of semantics? One amns miracle is another mans coincidence and all that.
I don't think the '73 Yom Kippur war could be called a huge victory for Israel, a lthough a victory I would agree it was. The six day war was very much swayed by the annhilation of the Egyptian and Syrian Air Forces in a very short space of time. This was achieved by very good management of the aircraft, the IDF were turning aircraft around between sorties in a matter of minutes instead of the usual hours.
I don't know muchn about the '48 and '56 conflicts though.
For the record, I'm an atheist and I'm very critical of most things religious but from a poltical POV, I'm more on the side of Israel than her neighbours. A pro-Jew Atheist?
Strange but true...
A miracle is surely a matter of semantics? One amns miracle is another mans coincidence and all that.
I don't think the '73 Yom Kippur war could be called a huge victory for Israel, a lthough a victory I would agree it was. The six day war was very much swayed by the annhilation of the Egyptian and Syrian Air Forces in a very short space of time. This was achieved by very good management of the aircraft, the IDF were turning aircraft around between sorties in a matter of minutes instead of the usual hours.
I don't know muchn about the '48 and '56 conflicts though.
For the record, I'm an atheist and I'm very critical of most things religious but from a poltical POV, I'm more on the side of Israel than her neighbours. A pro-Jew Atheist?
Strange but true...
OK, I've been thinking a bit more about this instead of working ;-), and sorry for going slightly off-topic but here goes:
God might have intervened to help the Israeli cause in some of the conflicts you mention Mr T.
What happened on 11th September? A lot of Jews were in the WTC when it was attacked by Arab extremists. Was the big fella perhaps asleep at the big red miracle button?
OK, so it wasn't an attack directly on the holy land.
What about the dozens (hundreds?) of Israelis killed in the Lebanese conflict last year? Why didn't He intervene and say, throw a tsuanmi at the Hezbollah rebels? Or was it OK because Israel knocked the $hit out of Lebanon?
What about the Iranian president making bold claims about wiping the state iof israel off the map? Why hasn't he been struck by lightning or had an anyeurism while on the khazi? Or do you think the fact iran haven't yet managed to build a fission (or much worse, a fusion weapon) is Gods intervention?
What about the Holocaust? Why did He let it go on for so long, why didn't Hitler fall down the stairs or something? Why did God let it take 6 years to assemble the allied forces and defeat the nazis? Why didn't God strike when the first jews went to the camps?
Ok, maybe a bit tongue in cheek but it's a serious question.
At what point will God decide that enough's enough and just send a plague to every anti-semite on the planet? Then Israel can have the whole of the Middle East to themselves.
This a Good Topic :-)
God might have intervened to help the Israeli cause in some of the conflicts you mention Mr T.
What happened on 11th September? A lot of Jews were in the WTC when it was attacked by Arab extremists. Was the big fella perhaps asleep at the big red miracle button?
OK, so it wasn't an attack directly on the holy land.
What about the dozens (hundreds?) of Israelis killed in the Lebanese conflict last year? Why didn't He intervene and say, throw a tsuanmi at the Hezbollah rebels? Or was it OK because Israel knocked the $hit out of Lebanon?
What about the Iranian president making bold claims about wiping the state iof israel off the map? Why hasn't he been struck by lightning or had an anyeurism while on the khazi? Or do you think the fact iran haven't yet managed to build a fission (or much worse, a fusion weapon) is Gods intervention?
What about the Holocaust? Why did He let it go on for so long, why didn't Hitler fall down the stairs or something? Why did God let it take 6 years to assemble the allied forces and defeat the nazis? Why didn't God strike when the first jews went to the camps?
Ok, maybe a bit tongue in cheek but it's a serious question.
At what point will God decide that enough's enough and just send a plague to every anti-semite on the planet? Then Israel can have the whole of the Middle East to themselves.
This a Good Topic :-)
come off it.
Why are you not on here saying that Ariel Sharon was struck down by that stroke that put him into a persistant vegetative state as a punishment from God.
We all know full well that if Yassa Arafat had suffered the same fate you'd be on here claiming divine intervention.
You're just picking your "Miracles" again.
Why are you not on here saying that Ariel Sharon was struck down by that stroke that put him into a persistant vegetative state as a punishment from God.
We all know full well that if Yassa Arafat had suffered the same fate you'd be on here claiming divine intervention.
You're just picking your "Miracles" again.
-- answer removed --
jollygreen - The fact remains that by any normal reckoning, Israel, according to military experts, should have lost. Particularly so in the 1948 war of independence, when the Arabs, who had allied themselves with the Germans throughout WW2, pledged to kill off the fledgling state.
As to all of the "whys" asking about Gods lack of intervention elswhwhere, this is well documented in the Bible.
But Israel, now, today, is indeed a living miracle of survival, there's no denying that.
As to all of the "whys" asking about Gods lack of intervention elswhwhere, this is well documented in the Bible.
But Israel, now, today, is indeed a living miracle of survival, there's no denying that.
I do not know much about politics and wars, but I do know when the six day war took place, I had a very close relative who was serving on board the USS Liberty.
That ship was horrifically attacked by Israel and 34 US servicemen were killed. Over a hundred were wounded badly and that ship had very little protection on board. The ship was bombed and torpedoed continually and most of those men suffered trauma for the rest of their lives.
I find it hard to call that getting lucky or a miracle on Israel's part. I do know that people are killed in wars all the time, but my relative suffered a lot after that attack and that ship was not at war.
That ship was horrifically attacked by Israel and 34 US servicemen were killed. Over a hundred were wounded badly and that ship had very little protection on board. The ship was bombed and torpedoed continually and most of those men suffered trauma for the rest of their lives.
I find it hard to call that getting lucky or a miracle on Israel's part. I do know that people are killed in wars all the time, but my relative suffered a lot after that attack and that ship was not at war.
1 to 20 of 20
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.