News0 min ago
Invasion of Poland 1939
Why did Great Britian declare war on Germany when she invaded Poland in September 1939 but not Russia when she invaded 2 weeks later?
Answers
1 to 4 of 4
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Pootle. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
I am not sure the link above explains why Great Britain did NOT declare war on Russia.
I am sure others may come up with a detailed answer, but from my understanding of the situation, while our dislike of Germany had been strong for a long time, the Soviet Union had, until recently, been considered an ally of Great Britain (and France).
When Germany invaded Poland (and we had agreed to support Poland) it took very little for us to declare war on them.
When the Soviet Union invaded Poland I think it took us by surprise and we were not so ready to declare war on them.
One web site I saw said we (and France) tried to get them thrown out of the League of Nations, but that sounds more like a slap on the wrist compared with declaring war.
I am sure others may come up with a detailed answer, but from my understanding of the situation, while our dislike of Germany had been strong for a long time, the Soviet Union had, until recently, been considered an ally of Great Britain (and France).
When Germany invaded Poland (and we had agreed to support Poland) it took very little for us to declare war on them.
When the Soviet Union invaded Poland I think it took us by surprise and we were not so ready to declare war on them.
One web site I saw said we (and France) tried to get them thrown out of the League of Nations, but that sounds more like a slap on the wrist compared with declaring war.
Perhaps a few of the following might help in your overall understanding of the situation in the late nineteen thirties.
France and Germany had promised Poland that if she was invaded by Germany, as had Czechoslovakia, then F and GB would come to her aid and defend. Germany invaded and thus the promise was instigated.
Russia was not a 'natural' enemy of Great Britain in the sense that Germany had been biting our heels for years, not least the Great War itself. So it could well have been seen that Russia was holding back the inevitable German invasion by becoming friends with Hitler to give Stalin time and space to re arm and get his act together. GB by virtue of the fact that war was agin Germany and all her allies, ie the axis, meant we were not in the same bed as Stalin at that moment.
Later when Germany decided to rub out Russia Stalin switched sides and then began to use the allied forces to defend the Russian Motherland, and many historians believe that was always his primary intention closely followed by an expansionist policy in line with the Communist doctrine.
Stalin was not on Churchills Christmas card list as his worry was that maybe together we would win the war but would there be Russian troops at the Pas de Calais in so doing. A tricky balancing act for Churchilll to manage.
Therefore to relate to your original point there was no formal declaration because the war politics were so fluid. Hitler never intended to be friends of Stalin, the Allies preferred Stalin in the team than outside it but it all had to be skillfully managed.
All in all I think we did well even though Russian territory was expanded considerably at wars end. Now of course it has changed yet again.
France and Germany had promised Poland that if she was invaded by Germany, as had Czechoslovakia, then F and GB would come to her aid and defend. Germany invaded and thus the promise was instigated.
Russia was not a 'natural' enemy of Great Britain in the sense that Germany had been biting our heels for years, not least the Great War itself. So it could well have been seen that Russia was holding back the inevitable German invasion by becoming friends with Hitler to give Stalin time and space to re arm and get his act together. GB by virtue of the fact that war was agin Germany and all her allies, ie the axis, meant we were not in the same bed as Stalin at that moment.
Later when Germany decided to rub out Russia Stalin switched sides and then began to use the allied forces to defend the Russian Motherland, and many historians believe that was always his primary intention closely followed by an expansionist policy in line with the Communist doctrine.
Stalin was not on Churchills Christmas card list as his worry was that maybe together we would win the war but would there be Russian troops at the Pas de Calais in so doing. A tricky balancing act for Churchilll to manage.
Therefore to relate to your original point there was no formal declaration because the war politics were so fluid. Hitler never intended to be friends of Stalin, the Allies preferred Stalin in the team than outside it but it all had to be skillfully managed.
All in all I think we did well even though Russian territory was expanded considerably at wars end. Now of course it has changed yet again.
1 to 4 of 4
