I think it's quite funny, I didn't take it like that 2sp, I took it that you expected the third guy to say 'I like rearing beef' because he looked masculine ( with a beard etc) and then suddenly he went against type and said ' I like big glossy musicals'.lol. I like all the Aldi adverts in fact.
I usually like the Aldi adverts, but I just found this one fell short of the usual humour.
I can see where you are coming from, Shar. I think if it didn't have "Man A, Man B, Beef Farmers and Luke" written at the bottom I would have seen it from your point of view.
If they hadn't stated that Luke wasn't a farmer I probably would have liked it.
It makes sense I took it also that Luke was less masculane, but I dont think it is funny, not a patch on the woman that likes the gin that was the best