Can You See The Flaw In This Decision? Re Obese Trans Woman

[barry1010]

Judge ruled that gym users in the changing room could not have seen this naked woman's penis because her hanging belly obscured it.
If that were the case how did the women know this woman still had her penis?
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12054769/Trans-woman-cleared-flashing-penis-YMCA-shes-FAT-genitals-visible.html

Pat on the back for me for keeping a straight face whilst typing 'her penis'.

[Old_Geezer]

According to the link, it's "shes fat genitals". You really must get your grammar right barry.

[DTCwordfan]

well she has a mini one whatever, it's called a clitoris - they come from the same cells in the early days of baby growth.

[Deskdiary]

“Her penis”.

It’s just patently absurd isn’t it.

[New Judge]

//It’s just patently absurd isn’t it.//

Indeed it is, DD. The problem is that to suggest it is labels you as a bigoted old fart by some on here, and that your views are similar to those who opposed gay rights fifty years ago.

The biggest flaw I see in the decision is that it considers solely what the women can or cannot see whilst in their changing room. It doesn't consider what the grossly obese bloke who has invaded them might see whilst he's wandering around with his guts (if nothing else) on display.

[naomi24]

The mere fact that this person is being referred to by presumably sane people, ie the judge, the lawyers- and the newspaper - in female terms serves only to encourage and endorse the lie. He is not a she or a her. He’s a bloke!

[Peter Pedant]

smut on coronation day + 1
it has to be AB !

Geoffrey Dickinson MP was the one who said
no one wants compulsory lesbianism thrust down our throats!

[Peter Pedant]

erm can I help that George IV ever the one for publicity, women and full meals
had "an apron" that hung down to his knees
and in deshabille ( daze zabeeee - - nuddy - no clothes on) was carried around by a servant

[William51]

I think the judge was laughing inside. He knew this was a malicious nonsense case and gave a fudge ruling to end it.

[seekeerz]

I’m curious why all these women were in the yMca - or is it one big happy family now ?

[barry1010]

The YMCA gyms and sports facilities have been open to women and families for years, even in the UK https://www.ymca.org.uk/about/what-we-do/health-and-wellbeing

[seekeerz]

Thanks Barry, I’ve learnt something new !! Not sure how much use it will be, but thanks anyway :)

[barry1010]

I've seen some horrible sights in changing rooms over the years (often when I've looked in the mirror by mistake) and I know it is possible to see an obese man's genitals from behind when he bends down.
It is particularly unpleasant when I am sat down pulling my socks on and a man does it in front of me.
Hope I haven't put you off your breakfasts

[MissTerious2]

Oh Barry! You've just ruined my impressions of you. I imagined you as a perfect adonis. ;0)

[barry1010]

My wife thinks I am

[Togo]

In the gym?? Ridiculous. Should have been at weight watchers.

[Togo]

Haha Not you Barry. :))

[Gromit]

// how did the women know this woman still had her penis? //

The report explains that a YMCA employee had informed one of them. Did you not read the article?

[Ken4155]

Some bad language;

[naomi24]

I recommended that a couple of weeks ago, Ken. Superb!

[barry1010]

Gromit, I did indeed read the article which only states that the employee told the ladies that complained that she identifies as a woman, not that she still had her penis.