ChatterBank0 min ago
Should We Create A Third Gender?
116 Answers
Given all the controversy over the transgender issue and whether or not men who self-identify as women should be allowed to use women’s facilities, should we establish an accepted third gender as I believe some other countries have, and allocate those people separate spaces?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by naomi24. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Jim, //the answer cannot be (or cannot merely be) to create more segregation by sex or gender,//
But by the very nature of trans people they are separate simply because they don’t ‘fit’ into either of the two existing categories. The may ‘self-identify’ but that doesn’t mean they are what they claim to be. They’re not.
//because the other factor that was overlooked in the post is that most of the sexual assaults in prisons involve women attacking other women or men attacking other men.//
That’s skirting the issue completely.
But by the very nature of trans people they are separate simply because they don’t ‘fit’ into either of the two existing categories. The may ‘self-identify’ but that doesn’t mean they are what they claim to be. They’re not.
//because the other factor that was overlooked in the post is that most of the sexual assaults in prisons involve women attacking other women or men attacking other men.//
That’s skirting the issue completely.
Transgender people in prison, as a percentage (Jim will know) have attacked, far more than women have. One point, which nobody seems bothered about, is that it's literally about what sex you are. I would have much less chance against a man, than another women. Nobody objects to lesbians being in a female prison. It isn't about gender, sexuality etc. It's about sex.
Totally wrong, roadman. Trangender males, have exactly the same statistics as males for violence. Trans -or even transexual, doesn't change that.
A woman is no more and no less likely to be attacked by a transgender male than any other. Those not wanting to share private space with a man, would (or logically should) have exactly the same wariness with a transgender man.
It's the typical "not all men". But it only takes one.
A woman is no more and no less likely to be attacked by a transgender male than any other. Those not wanting to share private space with a man, would (or logically should) have exactly the same wariness with a transgender man.
It's the typical "not all men". But it only takes one.
https:/
//transformed retain the male pattern of male violent crime//
However, look it up wherever you like- the truth remains the truth.
//transformed retain the male pattern of male violent crime//
However, look it up wherever you like- the truth remains the truth.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.