Aprilis has hit the nail on the head! I got together with my partner after a succession of failed relationships, mostly with men who were charmers who put their own needs above mine. Then I met Martin. He was confident and independent. Although initially romantic, taking me out for meals and buying me flowers for valentines day, it gradually petered out as the months and years rolled on. Now I have to remind him when it is my birthday and I have not seen a bunch of flowers in years. We also never hold hands in public, he never cuddles me or tells me that I look good, except very occaisonally.
Does any of that matter to me? No! He is incredibly supportive in practical ways, when I went through an extremely stressful time in my previous employment, he dealt with all the practical problems and gave me a lot of good advice. I can rely on him 100% in day to day issues and I know that he will never let me down, he is hard working and extremely practical. He can fix anything he turns his hand to and my parents love him! Equally he knows he can rely on me 100%. We know that we love each other, we don't need to tell each other that all the time, we have now been together 20 years and are happy to spend the rest of our lives together.
My feelings are that loving words and gestures are easy to say, but completly worthless if they cannot be backed up by actions. If your man is supportive in other practical means, I think you would be mad to give up on this relationship until you are very definately certain that it is going nowhere.
I wish you all the best, you sound like a very sensible person who I am sure will weigh up all the pros and cons.
All the best, Sue