Good Ole E C H R.......another Nail I The Coffin For Women's Sport.

[ToraToraTora]

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/athletics/66162083
....why doesn't he race with the men? I think I know! He has a Y chromosome after all.

[Untitled]

I did not say that chromosomes can change after birth... i said that some women are born with Y chromosomes effectively because various disorders prevent the development of male physiology... you are simply wrong on this issue toratoratora... it is not a matter of opinion

[Untitled]

"How pleased would you be to have a daughter that trained hard for the Olympics only to see her lose out to a bloke?"

the person you are talking about is a woman... if my daughter lost to another woman i would feel immensely proud of her for getting to the olympics and showing such dedication and skill... what an odd thing to ask

[ToraToraTora]

untitled; "I did not say that chromosomes can change after birth... "
at 14:27, I said: "No medical condition changes chromosomes untitled. People are born with what they have. "
at 14:42 you said "you are not correct Tora" - it seems by your own admission that I was.
at 15:29 - "you are factually incorrect " - so you now admit that was wrong also??

[ToraToraTora]

16:58, You'd sacrifice years of hard work by your own daughter so you can be some sort of woke champion to a 1 in a million person? I suppose it tells me all I need to know.

[Untitled]

a nice try but the statement i was talking about there was this one:

"He is NOT female, there is a Y chromosome present, end of. "

i have never said that chromosomes can change... you introduced that as a straw man

[Untitled]

my daughter would not need to win in order for me to love and admire her toratoratora

[ToraToraTora]

Well you should have been more specific about what you were addressing. Sad that you are so determined that you are right that you would sacrifice the dreams of actual women including your own kin.

[Untitled]

as i have been very patiently trying to explain to you... women with hormonal disorders are as much women as any hypothetical daughter of mine (whom you assume has no such disorders) and they have every right to pursue their dreams too...

have you yet found any scientific evidence to prove that high testosterone provides a significant advantage?

[ToraToraTora]

....even if they need to be chemically handicapped to compete? (not any longer) Are you reading the garbage you are writing?

[Untitled]

that rule was introduced very recently and was criticised by the BMJ for having no scientific basis

[bazwillrun]

^

Jeez louise, you just dont know when to stop....you just keep banging on to get the last word in...

[Khandro]

Untitled, You are beginning to sound as if you have some personal issue with this really obscure topic.

May I remind you that so-called transgender people represent an estimated 0.3 percent of the population.

[tomus42]

How do you know this person has a Y chromosome?

I read this..//
legally identified as female at birth but has a condition which means that she naturally produces higher levels of testosterone.//

[Untitled]

may i remind you that this person is not transgender