MIBs - of course I'm confused by your posts on reason.
The trouble is that you leave everything hanging, not anchored to anything.
Do you reject objective moral absolutes?
If so, then like Dawkins, you can see the universe as totally indifferent to our notions of good and evil.
Most of us, apart from the psychopath, can immediately recognise evil.
Auswitch, child murders, the sad list goes on and on.
But your airy fairy notions of right and wrong, encapsulated within your reason are nowhere defined, and like a rudderless ship, driven by the winds of change, or in this case, the latest thinking from experimental philosophers.
High falutin' sounding words are no substitute for the foundation stone of our being, with its duties and responsibilities towards each other, non negotiable, permanent and objective.