Quizzes & Puzzles1 min ago
Why In The Uk Has There Been No Arrest For This Disgusting Mutilation Practice?
252 Answers
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by anotheoldgit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Bigbad
I don’t think that’s the case. There is another example which proves this...look at scarification, and how it’s died out within a generation.
I think that you’re right in that the difficulty in tackling FGM is that it is by nature, hidden. However, it’s probably an over-simplification to suggest that ‘backward’ people whom have undergone this process cannot be educated.
That would suggest that they do not have any self-determination or ability to change from the attitudes of their parents.
This is not what I’ve observed. There was a girl I grew up with who this was done to. I only found out when I realised she had started a campaign group to highlight the issue.
I’m not sure what exposure you have had to girls who have suffered this procedure - did they tell you that they would inflict in on their daughters too?
What did you say to them when they said that?
I don’t think that’s the case. There is another example which proves this...look at scarification, and how it’s died out within a generation.
I think that you’re right in that the difficulty in tackling FGM is that it is by nature, hidden. However, it’s probably an over-simplification to suggest that ‘backward’ people whom have undergone this process cannot be educated.
That would suggest that they do not have any self-determination or ability to change from the attitudes of their parents.
This is not what I’ve observed. There was a girl I grew up with who this was done to. I only found out when I realised she had started a campaign group to highlight the issue.
I’m not sure what exposure you have had to girls who have suffered this procedure - did they tell you that they would inflict in on their daughters too?
What did you say to them when they said that?
naomi24
Simple question...how do you prove a girl has undergone FGM.
That’s the crux of the issue, and why some of the ideas put forward would be difficult to implement - such as examining girls who travel to certain areas in Africa before they go, and when they come back.
This would have to be an invasive vaginal examination.
Or am I missing something?
Simple question...how do you prove a girl has undergone FGM.
That’s the crux of the issue, and why some of the ideas put forward would be difficult to implement - such as examining girls who travel to certain areas in Africa before they go, and when they come back.
This would have to be an invasive vaginal examination.
Or am I missing something?
sp, since Zacs hasn’t had the courtesy to pass my message on to you, I’ll do it myself. This is what I wrote. // a vaginal examination is what we ladies might call an 'internal' - and that is not necessary.//
Zacs, you didn’t have to ‘wheedle’ it out of me. It hadn't occurred to me that you were so very ignorant of female anatomy, that's all.
Zacs, you didn’t have to ‘wheedle’ it out of me. It hadn't occurred to me that you were so very ignorant of female anatomy, that's all.
We have now moved on to 'biological definitions', it seems.
Perhaps the phrase 'genital examination' should have been used thereby distinguishing between a visual look at the appropriate area and an 'vaginal/internal' which would have been a bit after-the-fact and pointless.
Although, anyone with half a brain would have known was intended even if the words were medically correct....
Perhaps the phrase 'genital examination' should have been used thereby distinguishing between a visual look at the appropriate area and an 'vaginal/internal' which would have been a bit after-the-fact and pointless.
Although, anyone with half a brain would have known was intended even if the words were medically correct....
I’m sure you can guess, sp, that I have no experience of women or girls who have suffered this procedure, and just because you know of one person, that doesn’t make you any more of an authority on the subject than I am!
There have been threads where you and I have disagreed on ‘educating’ the backwards’ before.
And whilst I don’t want to divert AOG’s thread, I can only hold up that discussion as an example, which was about the starving Africans.
For all the education we have tried on them, (starving Africans) and for all the years I have been around (I believe you and I are a similar age) absolutely nothing has worked.
Probably because they don’t want it to work. They would rather keep up tradition, than go against the grain.
I also think that “backwards” is a very appropriate description.
The educated world moves forward, (not always in a good way, of course) but those whose lives are mired in ancient religions/traditions stand still, and if they are still keeping up certain traditions that have no place in todays society, after many centuries have passed, then that makes them backwards.
There have been threads where you and I have disagreed on ‘educating’ the backwards’ before.
And whilst I don’t want to divert AOG’s thread, I can only hold up that discussion as an example, which was about the starving Africans.
For all the education we have tried on them, (starving Africans) and for all the years I have been around (I believe you and I are a similar age) absolutely nothing has worked.
Probably because they don’t want it to work. They would rather keep up tradition, than go against the grain.
I also think that “backwards” is a very appropriate description.
The educated world moves forward, (not always in a good way, of course) but those whose lives are mired in ancient religions/traditions stand still, and if they are still keeping up certain traditions that have no place in todays society, after many centuries have passed, then that makes them backwards.
Here's a simple step we could take.
As uncomfortable as it is why do we not seen any ad-breaks covering FGM?
We often see ad-breaks telling us about the perils of cigarettes. Why not run one on FGM directly on the watershed ... when kids are supposed to be in bed but as we know they are not in bed.
Put some pressure on the criminals abusing their kids.
Kids welfare before any religious or cultural bullcrap imo.
As uncomfortable as it is why do we not seen any ad-breaks covering FGM?
We often see ad-breaks telling us about the perils of cigarettes. Why not run one on FGM directly on the watershed ... when kids are supposed to be in bed but as we know they are not in bed.
Put some pressure on the criminals abusing their kids.
Kids welfare before any religious or cultural bullcrap imo.
Bigbad
I think you don’t quite understand what’s going on.
In Africa, there are states which have moved to make the practice illegal with prosecutions and jail terms given to those who practice FGM.
People need to understand what’s actually happening on the ground, and that the issue is not only being addressed here, but in these ‘backward’ countries.
naomi24 - it’s great that these women could openly discuss this with you. I hope you were in a position to offer them guidance point them to resources which might help them go in a different direction.
Hopefully they were the kind of women who could be educated and weren’t ‘backward’.
I think you don’t quite understand what’s going on.
In Africa, there are states which have moved to make the practice illegal with prosecutions and jail terms given to those who practice FGM.
People need to understand what’s actually happening on the ground, and that the issue is not only being addressed here, but in these ‘backward’ countries.
naomi24 - it’s great that these women could openly discuss this with you. I hope you were in a position to offer them guidance point them to resources which might help them go in a different direction.
Hopefully they were the kind of women who could be educated and weren’t ‘backward’.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.