I think you're missing the point, DD. I have no idea how she personally feels about it. But, she isn't some insecure teenager, in what way do you think she appreciates or requires an older unattractive stranger, grading what she looks like? He can, and should keep it to himself. I would be amazed if she was insecure enough to need his opinion. This is a daily, constant thing for most women- it isn't just "she's pretty". And- he was supposed to be in a professional capacity. I was surprised to see he was only 53, I would have guessed 15 years older- from his comment, not from his looks.